Monday 24th January: The problem with the "riches in niches" philosophy

Good morning! Today's newsletter is brought to you by Esther.

The last few years has demonstrated that there are "riches in niches" (yes...it doesn't rhyme in British English, but moving on...!) Generalised scale plays have largely struggled to effectively monetise audiences, while those that have gone narrow and deep are doing pretty well for themselves.

In this week's issue of his newsletter, Brian Morrissey looks at how publishers, whilst carving out their niche, end up defaulting to catering to rich elites. This is problematic because, as he points out, "The biggest challenges facing societies in the future - climate change, inequality, migration - all disproportionately affect the non-rich. It's hard to see how trust in news can be reversed if much of it is directed towards and caters to the rich."

Morrissey wants to see new monetisation models emerge that "strike the balance between broad access and sustainable economics" in more than just non-profit organisations. It's something the founders of the four local news start-ups spoke about too in last week's special podcast: the need to keep vital information free for all, but trying to build out membership schemes and other revenue streams to sustain them.

On a related note...! This Q&A from CJR's Covering Climate Now takes a look at the work of the Uproot Project, a network for environmental journalists of colour. They are aiming to bring a greater diversity of voices to the forefront of climate and environment stories, both by encouraging more journalists of colour to get interested in those beats, but also by supporting those already working on them to get their stories heard by bigger newsrooms.

This perfectly illustrates the "riches in niches" philosophy. Axios, who have been absolute pros at niche newsletters for elite audiences, have just launched three premium newsletters covering fintech, health tech and retail, which you can subscribe to for $599 a year each. They're also planning two more in media deals and climate deals (???) by the end of Q1.

To say Instagram has been slow off the mark here is an understatement. But then they've also only allowed linking out from Stories in the past few months. After Instagram's announcement last week, TikTok made it known that they too are testing paid subscriptions. The fight to be the best platform for creators is heating up.

This week's podcast:

We couldn't get our schedules to line up this weekend (thank you vaccines and science for ensuring we can actually have plans again!) so we'll be publishing this week's episode tomorrow instead. But do give last week's special episode a listen if you haven't already. FWIW I spent the whole weekend with family celebrating my daughter's first birthday...keep scrolling for a cute pic!

Become a supporter of the Media Voices team today! ❤️ Just head over to our KO-FI page and make a one-off contribution or sign up to support us every month. Every contribution help us to keep doing what we do and plan for more in the future.